Practice case · Hypothetical · Both
The Abfraction Problem
When a familiar diagnosis becomes an assumption.
All people, findings and preferences in this case are hypothetical. Do not enter patient information. Responses stay only in this open page; they are not sent, saved to browser storage or attached to analytics. Reloading or resetting clears them.
- 1 Look
- 2 Know
- 3 Decide
- 4 Make
- 5 Return
Stage 1 of 5 · Look
Describe the lesion before naming its cause
A hypothetical 47-year-old has shallow, wedge-shaped noncarious cervical lesions on two mandibular premolars, approximately 0.5 mm deep. Surfaces are firm; no cavitated caries is identified. Sensibility testing and percussion are normal. No mobility, sensitivity, esthetic concern or functional complaint is reported.
Comparable photographs from 12 months ago show no obvious change, though small changes may be missed. Mild wear facets are observed. The patient reports frequent acidic drinks and firm horizontal brushing. Findings, exposures and causal conclusions are different kinds of information.
Stage 2 of 5 · Know
Compare explanations against evidence
Mechanical loading: a plausible stress mechanism with observational associations; neither proves this patient’s cause or a benefit from changing the bite.
Chemical softening: the exposure history makes it worth examining timing and patterns, but does not isolate its contribution.
Abrasive wear: brushing can be relevant, particularly on susceptible surfaces; it is not established as the sole explanation here. These processes may interact.
The original teaching sources include Michael’s critical review, Silva’s clinical systematic review, Nascimento’s management review, and Maluf’s 25-year follow-up of 33 participants. Longitudinal association adds information but does not remove confounding. Review the full reference notes below.
Stage 3 of 5 · Decide
Choose within the evidence
In this stated case, no symptom, progression or structural problem requiring restoration has been established. Explore the patient’s concern and explain uncertainty. A preference-sensitive choice still needs a clinical rationale.
A “currency” is the outcome a perspective values. An “advocate” is who helps keep that outcome in the conversation. These lenses compare reasonable choices; they do not make unsupported explanations equally credible.
| Perspective | Outcome valued | Who represents it | Possible overlooked loss | Influence on the choice |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Biological | Retain a maintainable tooth | Clinician, with specialist input when needed | Additional sound tissue removed | Compare partial and full coverage where feasible |
| Patient | Comfort, time, affordability, confidence | The informed patient | Repeated visits or a bill they cannot manage | Ask which burden is hardest to carry |
| Future care | Repairability and options later | Patient and future treating clinician | A repairable problem becoming an extraction | Discuss failure modes, not only survival |
| Delivery | Reliable execution and follow-up | Clinician and care team | Technique or maintenance demands exceeding capacity | Confirm isolation, skill, access and review arrangements |
Stage 4 of 5 · Make
Make monitoring a real plan
Record location, size, sensitivity and photographs using a repeatable method. Review brushing and acid exposures without assigning a single cause. Set a risk-based reassessment date, and explain which symptoms or changes merit earlier contact. Reassess the indication for restoration if progression, persistent sensitivity or structural compromise develops.
Stage 5 of 5 · Return
Return to the finding and the explanation
No follow-up outcome is claimed. Ask what has changed: measured lesion progression, symptoms, function, patient goals, or new evidence. A change after advice alone would not automatically prove which cause was responsible.
Reflection complete. You have made your reasoning visible—not proved that one option is right for every patient.
References and evidence limitations
Focused teaching bibliography, checked November 9, 2026. This is not an exhaustive or systematic literature search. Full text was consulted for Nascimento et al.; the other summaries use PubMed abstracts.
- Michael JA, Townsend GC, Greenwood LF, Kaidonis JA. Abfraction: separating fact from fiction. Aust Dent J. 2009;54(1):2–8. PubMed, PMID 19228125. DOI: 10.1111/j.1834-7819.2008.01080.x. Critical narrative review: models and associations have limits when making causal claims.
- Silva AG et al. The association between occlusal factors and noncarious cervical lesions: a systematic review. J Dent. 2013;41(1):9–16. PubMed, PMID 23142094. DOI: 10.1016/j.jdent.2012.10.018. Heterogeneous clinical studies did not support altering occlusal factors to prevent or control NCCLs.
- Nascimento MM et al. Abfraction lesions: etiology, diagnosis, and treatment options. Clin Cosmet Investig Dent. 2016;8:79–87. Open full text, PMCID PMC4861607. DOI: 10.2147/CCIDE.S63465. Narrative management review; treatment suggestions are not a consensus guideline.
- Maluf CV, Lourenço EJV, Pegoraro LF, Telles DM. Noncarious cervical lesions: Response from a 25-year clinical follow-up study. J Prosthet Dent. 2025;134(3):653–661. Epub 2023. PubMed, PMID 38007292. DOI: 10.1016/j.prosdent.2023.11.001. Observational retrospective follow-up of 33 participants: associations included occlusal wear, interferences, and acidic diet. Longitudinal information supports investigation, but does not eliminate confounding or establish treatment benefit.